The name is a bit of an Italian-language lesson, too.
"So the story is, is that the building that we're in used to be the laundry facility for Baptist Hospital," said Lindsay. "Well, you make a sheet of pasta, they used to wash sheets in the building."
That's where pulito -- clean -- comes from.
"There's five tiers of Italian restaurants. So: Cafe Bar, Pizzeria, Trattoria, Osteria, and then Ristorante,"Lindsay explained. "Osteria is just right below that, so still approachable, but still a very good restaurant where you would go and celebrate something."
"So that came up and Pulito Osteria it was."
For Lindsay, it's a way to bring all the things he's seen and learned around the world back home to Belhaven.
"Seeing how happy people are when they leave or happy for their second reservation when they return, there's something very, very special about that," he said.
Lindsay said being on the recommended restaurants list is an honor -- and he's glad that's where the restaurant landed on the guide.
"Do we wanna push for the star? This is what we have to do, but then are we losing our identity as this restaurant that everyone feels comfortable in and is approachable?" he said.
"Being where we are at and our impact on the community, I think it's more important to make sure that everyone is comfortable coming in."